Best Fly for Bluegill: How to Fish the Gapen Bluegill Fly Kit

Updated: November 12, 2026. Prices checked on gapen.com Nov 12, 2026.

Best fly for bluegill, the short answer: a small, buggy fly with soft legs or hackle, size 10 to 12, fished slow on a floating line. There is no single magic pattern, which is why we sell the Gapen Bluegill Fly Kit: 18 hand-picked flies in a free clear fly box for $19.95. It covers the surface, the film and a few feet down, so you can find what the fish want that day.

Below: what kind of flies are in the kit, how to fish each type, a kit-vs-single-fly comparison, what to do in the cold months, and when a fly is the wrong tool for bluegill.

What makes a good bluegill fly?

A good bluegill fly is small enough for a bluegill's mouth, has something that moves when the fly sits still, and lands softly. Bluegill eat insects, nymphs and small bugs, and they often inspect a fly before they take it. Soft hackle, rubber legs and sponge bodies keep twitching after you stop stripping, and that is usually when the bite comes. Size matters more than color: go too big and you get pecks and short strikes instead of hookups.

What is in the Gapen Bluegill Fly Kit?

The kit is 18 hand-picked, hand-tied flies packed in a clear compartment fly box that comes free with the flies. Looking at the box in our product photos (it is labeled "18 Hand Picked Flies"), the mix runs three ways:

Fly type in the box Where it rides When to tie it on
Hackled and palmered bugs (brown, grizzly and black) On top or in the surface film Calm mornings and evenings, fish rising along weed edges and docks
Bead-head nymphs Sinks a foot or more below the surface Bright midday sun, wind, or fish holding a little deeper
Bright yellow and chartreuse patterns Just under the surface Stained water, cloudy days, or when the fish ignore natural colors

That spread is the point of a kit. Bluegill can move from the top to three feet down in an afternoon, and having all three styles in one box means you change flies instead of driving to the bait shop.

How do you fish a fly for bluegill?

The product page sums it up: floating line, short leader, docks, weed edges, lily pads and shallow flats, with a slow retrieve or a gentle twitch. Here is how we set it up at the shop:

  1. Rod and line: a light fly rod with floating line. Bluegill fight hard for their size, so a light rod makes a 7-inch fish fun.
  2. Leader: keep it short and simple, about the length of the rod or a little less. You are not fooling spooky trout here.
  3. Start on top: tie on a hackled bug, cast it tight to a dock post or weed edge, and let it sit until the rings disappear. Then give it one small twitch.
  4. Count it down: if nothing comes up, switch to a bead-head nymph, let it sink for a slow count, and strip it back in short 2 to 3 inch pulls with pauses.
  5. Watch the line, not just the fly: subsurface bites are often just a tick or a stop in the line. Lift the rod tip on anything odd.
  6. Move until you find a pod: where you catch one bluegill there are usually more. Once you get bit, slow down and work that spot.

Shop tip: if you get lots of pecks but few hookups, go down a size before you change color.

Bluegill Fly Kit vs buying single flies

If you already know your one pattern, buy it by the each. If you are new to fly fishing for panfish, or you want a box that covers different days, the kit is the better deal.

Option Price on gapen.com (Nov 12, 2026) Best for
Bluegill Fly Kit, 18 flies plus free box $19.95 (about $1.11 a fly) A first panfish fly box, gifts, or covering top to bottom
Sponge Spider From $1.94 each A floating sponge spider with legs to twitch over beds and weed edges
Beaded Bluegill Bug $1.45 each A beaded bug for summer casting or fishing slowly through the ice

Plenty of anglers do both: start with the kit, then restock the two or three patterns that catch the most fish on their pond.

Can you catch bluegill on a fly in the fall and winter?

Yes, but slow way down. The kit is built for spring and summer, when bluegill sit shallow and eat off the top. In late fall in Iowa and the rest of the Midwest, the best fly window is a sunny afternoon after a few warm days. Skip the dry patterns, fish a bead-head nymph deep and slow along the first weed edge or drop-off, and expect light bites. Once the lake locks up, the Beaded Bluegill Bug doubles as an ice fly: let it settle, twitch it up gently, and repeat. Winter is also a good time to stock a box so you are ready for the spring bedding bite.

When is a fly the wrong choice for bluegill?

  • Fish 10 feet or deeper: a fly on floating line will not get there. Use a small jig like an Ugly Bug or Jigets instead. For jig sizes and a float rig, see Best Bluegill Lures from Gapen.
  • Kids or spinning gear only: hang a small fly or jig under a Gapen Bream Float on a spinning rod.
  • Heavy wind: casting a light fly into a stiff breeze is no fun. Fish the calm side of the lake or switch to a float rig.

If you also fish for bass and trout, our guide on how to fish a Muddler Minnow covers Gapen's best-known fly.

Shop the Gapen Bluegill Fly Kit

Gapen Bluegill Fly Kit: 18 hand-picked, hand-tied bluegill and panfish flies in a free clear fly box, $19.95. Fish it on a floating line around docks, weed edges and lily pads. Shipping in the contiguous US is $7.95 on orders under $75, $3.95 on orders of $75 or more, and free on orders of $200 or more. Questions? Call the shop at 1-877-623-2099 and talk to an angler.

Best Fly for Bluegill FAQ

What is the best fly for bluegill?

A small, buggy fly with soft legs or hackle in about size 10 to 12, fished slowly. A mixed kit like the Gapen Bluegill Fly Kit lets you test top, film and subsurface patterns until one gets bit.

What size fly is best for bluegill?

Small. Bluegill have small mouths, so size 10 to 12 flies hook more fish than big bass bugs. If you get pecks without hookups, go smaller.

How many flies come in the Gapen Bluegill Fly Kit?

18 hand-picked flies, plus a free clear compartment fly box. The kit is $19.95 on gapen.com.

Do bluegill hit dry flies or wet flies?

Both. Dry and surface flies work best on calm mornings and evenings in warm weather. Bead-head nymphs and wet flies work better at midday, in wind, and in cold water.

What color fly is best for bluegill?

Start with natural browns, blacks and greys in clear water. Switch to yellow or chartreuse in stained water or on cloudy days.

Can I use bluegill flies for crappie?

Yes, crappie will eat them, especially the subsurface patterns. If crappie are your main target, look at the Gapen Crappie Fly Kit, which is built around brush piles, docks and timber.

Can you fly fish for bluegill without a fly rod?

Yes. Hang a small sinking fly under a light bobber on a spinning rod, or use a casting bubble. It is an easy way for kids to catch bluegill on flies.

Gapen Tackle Company, a family tackle shop in State Center, Iowa.